Welcome to our Beanstalk series: "Is This Normal?" Designed to answer your questions about child behavior and remind parents that the only thing truly "normal" about parenthood is that we're all in this together. Send your burning questions to beanstalk@tinybeans.com. All questions will be kept anonymous.

Art by Michelle Mildenberg

I sometimes joke that I could sleep on the edge of the Grand Canyon and not fall off. That’s what over seven years of co-sleeping will prepare you for—the ability to sleep on less than five inches of the bed with tiny feet smushed in your face. Although this method is what has mostly worked for my family, the pressure of perfect parenting reflected in social media had often left me wondering if my children not falling or staying asleep on their own fits the norm—and I have a feeling I’m not alone.

If we look beyond modern Western culture and recent human history, then the simple answer is, yes, it is normal for children to experience varying independent sleeping skills. From an anthropological viewpoint, parents—particularly mothers—sharing their sleep space with their young children is a centuries-old practice. And in some cultures, sleeping alone doesn’t occur until adulthood.

“Teaching our kids to sleep alone at a young age is a unique piece to Western culture and one that we often teach because we want our children to have experiences that require independent sleep skills, such as slumber parties and sleepaway camps,” says Emily McMason parent, coach, and sleep consultant at Evolving Parents.

Though it really does come down to personal preferences and the health of your family. If soothing your child to sleep or co-sleeping is what results in the best rest, then there’s little reason to change it while your child is very young. However, if it’s not working or you believe your child is old enough to begin an independent sleep routine, there are some steps you can take that do not involve traumatic experiences for you or your child.

According to Dr. Lynelle Schneeberg, pediatric sleep psychologist, assistant professor at the Yale School of Medicine, and fellow of the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, “Children often develop a sleep-onset association—also known as a sleep crutch. If you’re always there when your child falls asleep or co-sleep, they begin to pair parental presence with their ability to fall asleep. So, when you’re ready to teach independent sleep skills, start by figuring out what their sleep crutch is and gradually remove these things from their routine.”

In Dr. Schneeberg’s book Become Your Child’s Sleep Coach: The Bedtime Doctor’s 5-Step Guide, Ages 3-10, she recommends small steps such as placing a body pillow between you and your child, giving them a nighttime toy to sleep with, and moving them to their own bed but staying in the room until they learn to fall asleep without the need for your presence.

Furthermore, helping children understand the sleep cycles—that often differ for each family member—and providing a reason for them to be excited for sleeping on their own is an effective tool. And one that Emily McMason recommends, encouraging parents to help children understand why uninterrupted sleep is important with phrases such as “your body needs peaceful sleep to grow, and I can’t wait to see how much bigger you are in the morning!”

Whether you decide it’s time to transition your child to sleep on their own or want to embrace your child’s sleep dependencies, remember that the choice and experience are uniquely yours, and it’s unlikely you’ll be their sleep crutch forever.

—Candace Nagy

Mother. Writer. Lover of history and nature. Read more by Candace here.

10 Shows for Toddlers When You Need a Little Break

My sweet toddler's newest obsession is wrapping her chubby little arms around my thigh and holding on for dear life. While it is just about the cutest thing ever, it also makes lunch preparation, laundry folding and the occasional mindless social scrolling a little complicated. When I need a few (or 15) minutes all to myself, I turn on one of these ten shows that keep my little one entertained and learning while I sneak in a little alone time.


13 Montessori Toys We Love—And How They'll Help Your Toddler Learn

It was about halfway through our tour of the local Montessori school when I began to realize that the "Montessori way" was vastly different than the noisy, busy world my child had been surrounded by ever since we bought him his first "Musical Rainforest Bouncer."

The kids in this classroom—all of them between the ages of 2 and 4—were quietly (!) sitting at tables engaged in peculiar-looking activities that were, it turned out, specifically "Montessorian": A little girl scooped up tiny felt balls with a set of tongs and dropped them into little glass bowls; a boy slid small wooden cylinders into a board full of perfectly-sized holes; A small child tinkered with a markedly realistic-looking puzzle of the human body. All of these "toys," I was told, would help with things like handwriting, math skills, problem-solving.


5 Snacks I Always Keep in My Diaper Bag

It is a not-so-inside joke that snacks solve just about everything when it comes to toddlers. It's especially important to master the snack game when you like to take your toddlers out of the house as much as I do. Getting stuck without healthy snacks means we have to stop and grab some pretty unhealthy options. These five snacks are my go-to choices for stowing in my diaper bag as they keep everyone happy when we're out together.


We want to hear from you. Click here to take a quick survey and give us your feedback.